# Included Garbage Bag Scenario

## Question

What levy impact would result from including one garbage bag in each household's normal curbside garbage collection every other week?

This scenario treats the included bag as one of the existing permitted bags. Additional bags would remain subject to the City's bag-tag rules. The ordinary collection schedule is 26 collections per year. Downtown collection has a weekly variation, so the baseline below needs a separate downtown-unit count before it can be treated as a City-wide final estimate.

## Public baseline

- The City currently collects garbage every other week outside the downtown collection area.
- The current bag tag price is $3.00.
- The City's 2023 Waste Management Strategy says curbside waste service covers approximately 6,600 households.
- The 2026 Waste Management budget has a Waste Management Division Levy Requirement of $1,042,577.
- The detailed 2026 budget includes $391,500 for waste-transfer tipping fees and $1,232,609 for transfer-station contract services.
- The 2026 existing-resident tax requirement is $38,133,221.

Sources: City garbage collection information (https://www.owensound.ca/living-here/garbage-and-recycling/garbage-collection/), City Waste Management Strategy (https://www.owensound.ca/media/xuacibli/study-version-waste-management-strategy-owen-sound.pdf), 2026 Mayor's Budget (https://www.owensound.ca/media/lujd1fw3/2026-mayor-s-budget.pdf?DocumentId=50912), and the local 2026-budget-line-items.csv.

## Known levy pressure

At full use, one free bag per household per ordinary biweekly collection would replace the following tag purchases:

6,600 households x 26 collections x $3.00 = $514,800 per year

That is approximately:

- 49.38% of the 2026 Waste Management division levy requirement;
- 1.35% of the City's 2026 existing-resident tax requirement.

The public record also contains a newer rounded figure of nearly 7,800 residential units receiving green bins. As an upper planning check, that count gives:

7,800 units x 26 collections x $3.00 = $608,400 per year

That equals 58.36% of the Waste Management division levy requirement and 1.60% of the existing-resident tax requirement. The two household figures are retained as a sensitivity range because they come from different City documents and are not identical measures.

The calculations are in garbage-bag-included-scenario.csv.

## Additional waste cost

The tag-revenue loss is the known first-order levy pressure. Additional waste mass may also increase tipping fees. The public budget gives the total tipping-fee line but does not provide the current per-tonne contract rate or the average weight of a curbside bag.

At the 6,600-household baseline, 171,600 additional bags per year would represent approximately:

| Average bag weight | Additional annual material |
| ---: | ---: |
| 5 kg | 858 tonnes |
| 10 kg | 1,716 tonnes |
| 15 kg | 2,574 tonnes |
| 18 kg maximum allowed weight | 3,088.8 tonnes |

The 7,800-unit upper check would range from 1,014 to 3,650.4 additional tonnes. These figures are physical-volume sensitivities, not cost claims. The City's current tipping rate, waste composition, route capacity, and contract terms are needed to convert them into dollars. If collection routes or contract capacity change, those costs belong in the scenario as well.

## Preliminary conclusion

A universal included bag every other week creates a preliminary levy pressure of approximately **$515,000 to $608,000 per year before additional disposal, contract, administration, or downtown-frequency costs**. The strongest current budget-safe statement is that the tag-revenue portion alone is approximately $0.5-$0.6 million; the final levy effect requires current tag sales, household counts, disposal tonnage, marginal tipping rates, and contractor pricing.

The scenario should be tested against waste diversion. The City's Waste Management Strategy identifies bag-tag sales, curbside audits, waste-composition studies, and participation studies as useful measures. A pilot or staged change should publish those measures alongside the levy effect.

## Records needed for a final budget case

1. Annual bag tags sold by year, including downtown and non-downtown collection areas.
2. Current residential units and occupied households by collection frequency.
3. Curbside garbage bags and tonnes by route or collection period.
4. Current transfer-station tipping rate and marginal cost per tonne.
5. Miller Waste contract terms for additional volume, contamination, route capacity, and service changes.
6. Any change in illegal dumping, transfer-station use, recycling, or green-bin tonnage after implementation.
