• 0 posts
  • 9 comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 22nd, 2025

help-circle

  • I have no loyalty to Israel. Your blind disgust of anyone who doesn’t 110% agree with your semantics just makes you sound ignorant.
    I would agree that what Israel has been doing for a year now is genocide. Israel is attacking civilians with intent to destroy the people of Gaza for their religious/racial association. That’s genocide. However, before this, their stated goal was to eliminate the military capabilities of Hamas. It was war. Hamas was firing unguided rockets at Israel, Israel was hitting Hamas targets (with a terrible disregard for civilians casualties from proximity or poorly determined targets). That’s no more genocide than the UK bombing Nazi Germany’s military production areas in wwii. Typical uses of the term genocide in the past have involved selective targeting of particular races within an area, and the intent to ‘purify’ the population. This makes it even a stretch to apply the term to Israel now but it’s ambiguous because of the severe ethnic divide between Israel and Gaza. That said, there are plenty of Arabs and Muslims inside Israel (not including Gaza or wb). They are not being killed. They don’t have full rights, so one might call this an apartheid.
    So yes Israel is evil and should be stopped, but it’s important not to be revisionist here, especially regarding the democratic platform in the last US election vis a vis Israel. Making such a distinction between now and then allows things to change for the better. We can allow people to change their stance and now push back on Israel, which is the goal - not just crying about being a victim perpetually and assigning blame.



  • Not sure what newsletters you get, but please stop trying to project your narrow-mindedness on me.
    I would love it if the Dems were to run someone who was actually progressive and took a strong stance against violence. But the billionaire class owns the politicians and the media, so it’s literally impossible to go there too fast without a revolution. Too many Americans would be taken in by any media play to villainize a ‘communist’ candidate. Heck, the reason you hate Harris is partly from the efforts of the right wing media to sow division in the democrats so as to get their tax/regulation reducing guy in power. So we end up with a dem candidate who will still keep the billionaires happy. But it’s a simple fact of which viable candidate was better/worse. If you can’t see that Harris would have been better than trump by a lot, then you’re being willfully ignorant. And there’s a whole timeline issue with calling Harris a genocide supporter. At the time of the last election, Isreal was still arguably fighting Hamas who was still firing rockets daily at Israeli civilians after starting the latest escalation in the October attacks. Of course Isreal was committing human rights violations back then, as they have been for decades, but it wasn’t genocide by any reasonable definition at that point. Who knows how Harris would have reacted to the increased brutality and clearly unnecessary violence by Isreal? Probably Isreal wouldn’t have gone so far because of some pushback from a Harris administration. But there’s no way it would be as bad as under Trump, with Isreal basically directing the U.S. military and trump encouraging the complete destruction of Gaza and now Lebanon. So the failure to vote for Harris in the simple choice of her or Trump, is a direct cause of the worst violence against the Palestinians in a long time. Not to mention just about every other issue that failing to reject trump has damaged, from abortion rights, gay/trans rights, brutality against non-citizens, brutality against peaceful protestors, removal of environment protections, removal of healthcare funding, funding for science, funding for education/libraries, relations with international allies, dramatic cost of living increases, etc. All that for some moronic inability to choose the not-as-bad candidate. We need to do better. And if we actually get an election, we need to stop splitting hairs and dividing the left and get back some power so we can then push to clean things up. It’s either that or full blown revolution, but we know Americans don’t have the ability to do that for various excuses.



  • Many who hate musk because he is a Nazi actually would like the US to allow more immigration; to provide a path for immigrants already established to become ‘legal’. At the very least not treat them inhumanly. It’s only ideological coincident because these concepts are the logical, are aligned with decent values and sane.
    Musk and his ilk want ‘illegals’ removed, and so his hypocrisy should be called out - especially since this backwards thinking comes from the lack of empathy and recognition that immigrants are people just like everyone else with aspirations, capabilities, contributions - so much like everyone else that in fact musk is one of them.